Restaurant Testimonials from Customers of di Carlo

See what others are saying about Trattoria di Carlo & Catering and Pizzeria.

 As a board member of the South Suburban Chamber, I wanted to share a great experience that more than justified the value of a business being a member of the Chamber.
This past Saturday, my daughter’s dance group, Dance Repertoire, performed its end of the year showcase recital at the South Milwaukee High School PAC. After the show, we had the daunting task of finding a restaurant in the area that could accommodate 50 – 60 dancers and their parents at 10 p.m. on a Saturday night.

The week before, another parent was having difficulty finding a place to accept our challenging reservation count. I offered to look at our Chamber website and find a place.
I landed on Di Carlo’s Italian Restaurant.
Not only did they instantly accept our reservation, but the food and service was more than spectacular. We had our own private room. And while our children sat way across the room from their parents (of course, lol) the wait staff had no problem identifying whose kid belonged with each parent and conveniently added the right tab to the individual checks. (If you’ve ever been in a big group and in that situation with kids, you know how messy paying the bill can be.)
This restaurant capped off a perfect evening. I would never have found this place had I not checked the website member listing.  The power of positive networking!
We will definitely be back.
Terry Schuster, Oak Creek

Best pizza i’ve had in the Milwaukee area so far. i’m from out of town and took a chance with them, turned out great!!

Jenna, Oak Creek


We hired Di Carlos to cater a corporate event for us, every step of the way my coordinator Amy took care of  every thing that was needed, she asked the right questions to make sure she covered all of our needs.  On the day of the event the set up and food were perfect we could not have asked for anything better ! I would highly recommend this restaurant to cater any event that you have !  Thank you Amy and Carlo !!!

-Kim, Morton Grove IL


I ordered a cheese & sausage pizza last night from your carry out department and it was FABULOUS. Tons of sausage. I was able to use my Entertainment Coupon too but it’s worth full price! Just thought I’d let you know, thanks.

-Jean, Oak Creek

Had a fabulous meal with our family at Di Carlo’s August 17. Our server Mark, was very knowledgeable and made great recommendations. It was a delightful dining experience. Beautiful decor with a warm family atmosphere. This was our 5th time here and we will definitely return.

-Diane, Greenfield

We visited on July 16th from Indiana after being told you had the best pizza around. That was a understatement, all of our party of 9 agreed it was the best pizza we all ever had. Thanks for a great pizza and great dining experience. We never had a pizza with some many toppings! 

– Larry


A little over a month ago, I was recommended DiCarlo from a friend – Mindy was our server and she was awesome! She recommended a few dishes that my husband and I tried – each was amazing! Since our initial visit, we’ve been back at least once a week! You could say we’ve become DiCarlo-addicted! The most delicious pizza crust, super fresh toppings, amazing sauces and super fantastic service (such a great staff!): I suggest your restaurant to all of my friends and family!

– Michelle


Fantastic evening! The Staff did an outstanding job! We had a memorial dinner for our Mom, Grandma, Greatgrandmother & it was a very plesant event due to the friendly service & excellent food. no one left hungry! thank you all again!

-Marcia, Franklin


As an East Coast Italian from NJ who now lives in WI, I can tell you that di Carlo’s is the best! Food, Friendly people, great atmosphere!! Very reasonable prices for the QUALITY and the QUANTITY of food! And if you don’t see it on the menu, then just ask!! We were so happy to have a great Italian food establishment come to Oak Creek!!

-Angela & Les


We love di Carlo’s so much that we had our mom’s 90th Birthday Party there. We eat there at least once a week and sometimes more often. Really love the food



Pizza was amazing and all food was great had amazing service.

-James, Franklin


Your place is awesome!! Our server was Harmony and she was EXCELLANT!!! She made sure we were comforatble where we were seated and was attentive to all our dining needs. Very friendly. Can’t wait to come back.

-Lynn, Franklin


Don’t miss this wonderful Italian Restaurant. A little slice of Sicily. Great atmosphere, authentically gracious wait staff and delicious beautifully presented food. My family just through a surprise “60th” birthday party for me at di Carlo’s. Our guests from Minneapolis to Cleveland commented on this was the best most abundant buffet they had ever been to. The waiters moved among us taking and serving drink orders with grace and efficiency. Best birthday ever!!

-Sheila W.