Trattoria Di Carlo
  • Chef’s Menu
  • Drinks
    • Wine List
  • Rewards
  • Catering
    • Private Dining Rooms
    • Event Catering
    • Contact
  • Our Story
    • Meet Chef Carlo
    • Gallery
  • Contact
    • Employment
  • Order Online

Dinner

Dine-In Only:

Antipasti (Appetizers) Pinsa Romana (Roman-Style Pizza) Primo (Prime Selections) Insalate (Salads) Pollo (Chicken) Pesce e Frutti Di Mare (Fish & Seafood) Bistecca e Vitello (Steak & Veal) Parmiggiana (Parmigiana) Create your own Pizza Carlo’s Specialty Pizzas

Antipasti (Appetizers)

Calamari Fritti

dusted tender calamari fried golden brown, served with lemon, Sicilian caper aioli

$12.95

Shrimp Pesto Bruschetta

5 pieces char grilled italian bread, topped with diced tomato, evoo, garlic, basil, sautéed rock shrimp pesto and imported parmiggiano

$15.95

Bruschetta

five pieces char grilled italian bread, topped with diced tomato, evoo, garlic, basil and imported parmiggiano

$12.95

Mussels Marinara

fresh mussels, roasted garlic tomato basil sauce and grilled bread to clean the plate

$12.95

Eggplant Strips

battered eggplant, fried and served with house red sauce

$9.95

Mediterranean Octopus

char grilled octopus, parsley, garlic, lemon and evoo

$12.95

Mediterranean Seafood Grill

char grilled calamari, shrimp, and octopus dressed with fresh parsley, chopped garlic, lemon and evoo

$21.95

Spinach & Artichoke Spread

fresh artichokes, spinach, roasted garlic smothered in a creamy cheese sauce, served with grilled garlic bread

$9.95

Burrata Caprese

sliced tomato and burrata (a delicate mozzarella at its early stage of fresh mozzarella), topped with an aged balsamic glaze

$9.95

Gourmet Combo

bruschetta, mozzarella sticks, toasted cheese ravioli and eggplant strips

$12.95

Cheese Board

assorted imported and local cheeses, fresh fruit and local honey

$9.95

Antipasto Italiano

imported prosciuto, genoa salami, mortadella, marinated artichoke, roasted red peppers, mozzarella and parmiggiano reggiano

$16.95

Italian Sausage

italian sausage link with sautéed bell peppers and onions

$6.95

Grilled Oysters

parmiggiano and herb butter sauce grilled oysters

$9.95

Meatballs Marinara

oven roasted meatballs in our delicious red sauce

$9.95

Tuscan Charcuterie Board

borolo salami, mortadella, capicollo, parmiggiano, castelvetrano olives and marinated sun-dried tomatoes

$12.95

Pinsa Romana

Pinsa Romana is a modern twist on an ancient recipe. Dating back to ancient Roma, Pinsa combines Rice flour, Wheat flour and Soy flour to give you a healthier, more digestible amazingly flavorful alternative to pizza. Pinsa Romana only available in the following styles:

Rossa

Red Sauce

Margherita

pomodoro, basil, mozzarella and evoo

$12.95

Roasted Eggplant

pomodoro, basil, roasted eggplant, mozzarella and imported pecorino

$12.95

Capricciosa

pomodoro, prosciutto, mushrooms, artichokes and olives

$12.95

Italia

pomodoro, basil, mozzarella, arugula, sliced grape tomatoes, finished with imported parmiggiano and evoo

$12.95

Sausage & Pepperoni

pomodoro, basil, mozzarella,
italian sausage and pepperoni

$12.95

Bianca

White Sauce

Broccolini & Spicy Sausage

evoo, provolone, broccolini and spicy italian sausage

$12.95

Caprese

evoo, mozzarella, grape tomatoes, basil and balsamic glaze

$12.95

Bell Pepper, Roasted Potato & Italian Sausage

green peppers, roasted potatoes, italian sausage & mozzarella

$12.95

Rock Shrimp Pesto

evoo, mozzarella, rock shrimp,
sun-dried tomato and pesto sauce

$12.95

Spicy Italia

spicy Italian sausage and hot giardiniera

$12.95

Ortolana

evoo, mozzarella, green peppers,
red onion, sicilian olives, mushrooms, sun-dried tomato

$12.95

Primo (Prime Selections)

Chef Carlo’s handmade pastas are made with 100% semolina.

Rigatoni Shrimp & Avocado Pesto

sautéed rock shrimp, grape tomatoes, fresh basil, savory avocado pesto tossed with rigatoni and finished with parmiggiano reggiano

$16.95

Gnocchi Calabrese

spicy italian sausage, broccolini, shallots, garlic, evoo and imported parmesan with our house-made gnocchi

$15.95

Spaghetti alla Carbonara

sautéed bacon, prosciutto (italian ham) and onions served with spaghetti in
a creamy egg and parmesan sauce

$15.95

Classic Meat Lasagna

freshly made lasagna filled with specially seasoned meat sauce topped with red sauce and smothered with mozzarella

$15.95

Ricotta Cheese Lasagna

freshly made lasagna filled with seasoned ricotta cheese topped with red sauce and smothered with mozzarella

$15.95

Fettuccini Alfredo

fettuccine pasta smothered in our homemade alfredo sauce

$15.95 +$3.95 Roasted Chicken +$3.95 Rock Shrimp

Seafood Arrabiata

shrimp, scallops, and crab meat with a spicy marinara sauce tossed with angel hair pasta

$18.95

Spicy Shrimp

evoo, calabrian peppers, rock shrimp in a garlic cream sauce tossed with fusilli pasta

$16.95

Rotolo Primavera

homemade tomato, spinach and egg pasta rolled up between each layer is seasoned ricotta, and spinach. cooked to perfection and set on our delicious red sauce and covered with a white sauce

$15.95

Risotto & Cabernet Braised Beef

slowly braised beef and vegetables, served with arborio risotto and imported parmiggiano reggiano

$18.95

Parpadelle alla Bolognese Toscana

braised ground beef and pork with a vegetable and barolo red wine sauce

$16.95

Linguini Sugo di Gamberi

shrimp and scallops sautéed in a roasted garlic cherry tomato sauce and flamed with brandy tossed with house made linguini

$18.95

Fusilli Pulled Chicken Pesto

basil, parsley and garlic pesto sautéed with sun dried tomatoes and pulled chicken finished with parmiggiano reggiano

$16.95

Gnocchi Sardi

italian sausage, bell peppers, fresh oregano, onions in marinara sauce with homemade gnocchi

$16.95

Lobster Ravioli

a creamy marinara sauce sautéed with garlic, smothered with freshly cooked ravioli
filled with lobster

$16.95

Mushroom & Truffle Ravioli

roasted portabello, black truffle, ricotta herb filled ravioli topped with a sun-dried tomato pesto and pulled chicken

$15.95

Short Rib Ravioli

braised beef short ribs with vegetables and red wine filled ravioli served in a butter nutmeg sauce

$16.95

Spinach & Artichoke Ravioli

braised artichoke, fresh spinach and four cheese filling served in a pink vodka sauce

$15.95

Rigatoni Ortolana

zucchini, mushrooms, sun-dried tomato, sicilian olives in a pink vodka sauce

$15.95

Spaghetti alla Siciliana

fresh tomatoes, evoo, garlic, basil and sprinkle of parmesan served with spaghetti

$15.95 +$3.95 Rock Shrimp

Carlo’s Favorite Meatballs with Pasta

your choice of spaghetti, capellini or penne pasta and two meatballs topped with our delicious red sauce

$15.95

Baked Mostaccioli

mostaccioli topped with red sauce and smothered with mozzarella

$15.95

Tucson Fusilli & Chicken Sausage

roasted vegetables (red onion, celery, cherry tomatoes), savory chicken sausage glazed with a balsamic reduction and fresh herbs

$16.95

Pasta Flight

seasoned meat lasagna, angel hair pasta with pink vodka sauce and house made gnocchi with alfredo sauce

$18.95

Insalate (Salads)

Add chicken or shrimp / $5.00

Caprese Salad

fresh mozzarella, grape tomatoes, arugula, fresh basil tossed with a tangy aged balsamic vinaigrette

$6.95

Caesar Salad

romaine tossed with caesar dressing and croutons topped with shaved imported parmiggiano

$6.95

Sicilian Chef Salad

mixed lettuce with pepperoni, ham, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella, hardboiled egg and pepperoncini peppers with italian dressing

$6.95

House Salad

mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, croutons, and choice of dressing

$3.95

Pollo (Chicken)

Pollo Al Mattone (Traditional Roman Dish)

semi boneless chicken marinated for 24 hours, grilled with a “mattone” (heavy weight on to sear) will keep chicken tender and juicy, topped with a lemon, roasted garlic, rosemary sauce. served with a side of roasted potato and broccoli medley

$18.95

Chicken Marsala

thin sliced chicken breast, seared and simmered with mushroom, marsala wine imported from
our hometown “marsala”, served with seasonal vegetables and rosemary roasted potatoes

$18.95

Char Broiled Chicken Breast

boneless skinless chicken breast simmered in a tomato, basil, garlic sauce tossed with linguini

$18.95

Pollo Piccata

thin sliced chicken breast, seared and simmered in a white wine lemon caper sauce served with seasonal vegetables and rosemary roasted potatoes

$18.95

Pollo e Cous Cous

char-grilled chicken breast, toasted pearl cous cous sautéed with caramelized carrots and onions, and finished with a balsamic glaze

$18.95

Pesce e Frutti Di Mare (Fish & Seafood)

Salmon Pico de Gallo

grilled atlantic salmon, asparagus, roasted yukon gold potatoes, and a refreshing
pico de gallo sauce draped over salmon

$23.95

Citrus Honey Shrimp

honey, citrus marinated jumbo shrimp, seared and set on a cous cous bacon risotto

$23.95

Sea Bass

herb panko crusted sea bass, brown butter sauce, served over artichoke and sun-dried tomato risotto and seasonal vegetables

$23.95

Tilapia di Mare

seared tilapia, topped with a shrimp, scallop and sun-dried tomato
white wine cream sauce

$23.95

Bistecca e Vitello (Steak & Veal)

Veal provided by Wisconsin’s best, Strauss Brands.

Cast Iron Rib Eye

cast iron seared and finished with roasted garlic butter, yukon gold potatoes, roasted baby carrots dressed with an herb parsley pesto

$28.95

Filet Mignon

seasoned char-grilled served over an asiago potato cake, roasted vegetables and a fresh herb beef jus

$28.95 +$2.00 Roasted Garlic Stuffed +$2.00 Bacon & Bleu Cheese Stuffed

Mama’s Beef Spiedini

thin sliced beef rolled with prosciutto, green onions, provolone and herbs, served with rigatoni pink sauce

$21.95

Veal Osso Buco

slowly braised veal shanks in a white wine herb and vegetable stew, served over creamy polenta

$28.95

Veal Piccata

pan seared veal, simmered in a savory white wine sauce with Sicilian capers, roasted garlic and lemon, served with seasonal vegetables

$26.95

Veal Milanese

italian style breaded veal, pan seared, and served with peppery arugula ripe tomato with a lemon evoo zest

$26.95

Polenta Romana

creamy parmiggiano polenta, italian sausage and pork braised sauce with onions and fennel

$21.95

Parmiggiana

Veal Parmiggiana

choice veal breaded and topped with our delicious red sauce and mozzarella then baked to perfection. served with a side of pasta with red sauce

$21.95

Chicken Parmiggiana

breaded chicken breast topped with our delicious red sauce and mozzarella then baked to perfection. served with a side of pasta with red sauce

$18.95

Eggplant Parmiggiana

two pieces of eggplant topped with our delicious red sauce and mozzarella then baked to perfection. served with a side of pasta with red sauce

$18.95

Hand-Made Brick Oven Pizzas

The dough for Carlo’s Famous Original Crust is made fresh, then rested for exactly 24 hours. Carlo adds perfectly seasoned sauce, local and imported cheeses, and delicious toppings like pepperoni, sausage, green olives, and giardiniera.

Create Your Own Pizza

Choose your crust, sauce, and toppings (all styles include cheese).

Sauces: di Carlo Pizza Sauce, Garlic Butter, Pesto, Pink Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, EVOO, BBQ ($3), Chipotle ($3), Alfredo ($3)

10″ Small 12″ Medium 14″ Large 16″ XLarge 18″ Family.

Original Hand Tossed Crust

10″ $9.00
12″ $11.00
14″ $12.00
16″ $15.00
18″ $17

Extra Thin Crust

10″ $9.00
12″ $11.00
14″ $12.00
16″ $16.00
18″ $17.00

Thick Crust

10″ $12.00
12″ $13.50
14″ $14.50
16″ $18.50
18″ $19.50

Stuffed Chicago Style Crust

10″ $13.00
12″ $14.50
14″ $16.00
16″ $19.50

Pan Style Crust (2.5″ Thick)

10″ $13.00
12″ $14.50
14″ $16.00
16″ $19.50

Meat Toppings

sausage, pepperoni, ham, canadian bacon, bacon, ground beef, roasted chicken breast

10″ $1.20
12″ $1.45
14″ $1.75
16″ $2.00
18″ $2.25

Veggie Toppings

mushroom, onion, green pepper, green olives, black olives, broccoli, portobello, sliced roma tomatoes, pineapple, arugula, asparagus, hot giardiniera, mild giardiniera, spinach, sicilian jumbo olives, red onion, basil, roasted red pepper, pepperoncini

10″ $1.20
12″ $1.45
14″ $1.75
16″ $2.00
18″ $2.25

Chef Carlo’s Select Toppings

salami, chicken sausage, prosciutto, meatballs, provolone cheese, fontina cheese

10″ $2.00
12″ $3.00
14″ $3.50
16″ $4.00
18″ $5.00

Hand-Made Brick Oven Pizzas

The dough for Carlo’s Famous Original Crust is made fresh, then rested for exactly 24 hours. Carlo adds perfectly seasoned sauce, local and imported cheeses, and delicious toppings like pepperoni, sausage, green olives, and giardiniera.

Specialty Pizzas

10” Small 12” Medium 14” Large 16” XLarge 18” Family

O.C. Special (Oak Creek Special)

di carlo pizza sauce, mozzarella, sausage, mushroom, onion

10″ $12.95
12″ $14.95
14″ $15.95
16″ $19.95
18″ $21.95

Everything-But-The-Kitchen-Sink

cheese, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green pepper, green olives, black olives, bacon, onion

10″ $15.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $27.95

Hawaiian

cheese, pineapple, canadian bacon

10″ $12.95
12″ $14.95
14″ $16.95
16″ $19.95
18″ $22.95

Sicilian

cheese, fresh tomatoes, basil, artichoke and Parmesan cheese

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Vegetarian

cheese, onions, broccoli, fresh tomatoes, mushrooms

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Meatza

cheese, sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, Canadian bacon

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Chicken BBQ

cheese, grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, onions

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Pizza Bianca

cheese, fresh tomatoes, basil, alfredo sauce

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Farmers Market Delight

cheese, spinach, fresh tomatoes, asparagus, artichoke

10″ $15.95
12″ $19.95
14″ $22.95
16″ $27.95
18″ $29.95

Margherita

red sauce, mozzarella and basil

10″ $10.95
12″ $12.95
14″ $13.95
16″ $17.95
18″ $21.95

Quattro Stagioni

red sauce, mozzarella, prosciutto, tomatoes, marinated artichoke hearts, portobello mushrooms, sicilian olives

10″ $15.95
12″ $18.95
14″ $21.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $27.95

Frutti di Mare

evoo, sautéed calamari, crab meat, mozzarella, fresh tomatoes (tomatoes not cooked), and alfredo sauce drizzled on top

10″ $16.95
12″ $18.95
14″ $22.95
16″ $26.95
18″ $32.95

Carne

red sauce, mozzarella, prosciutto, salami, italian sausage and pepperoni

10″ $15.95
12″ $18.95
14″ $21.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $27.95

Sarda

red sauce, mozzarella, italian sausage, ricotta and evoo

10″ $15.95
12″ $18.95
14″ $21.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $27.95

4 Cheese

di carlo pizza sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, fontina, provolone

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Buffalo Chicken

buffalo sauce, mozzarella, roasted chicken breast, drizzled with ranch sauce

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95

Alfredo, Chicken & Broccoli

four cheese alfredo sauce, mozzarella, roasted chicken breast, broccoli

10″ $13.95
12″ $17.95
14″ $19.95
16″ $24.95
18″ $26.95
  • Chef’s Menu
  • Dinner
  • Lunch
  • Desserts
  • Events
  • Chef Carlo’s Preferred Selection
  • Carry-Out & Delivery
  • Monthly Specials

© 2021 Trattoria di Carlo | Designed by Savage Solutions